John Roberts Anti-Comfort Wish: May Hardship Teach You Justice, Loyalty, and Empathy
Most commencement speeches sound like a cup of warm water with sugar in it.
May your future be bright. May your road be smooth. May your dreams come true. May the world treat you gently. These words are pleasant, but they often disappear as quickly as the applause in the hall.
Chief Justice John Roberts, however, gave his son’s graduating class a very different kind of blessing.
In June 2017, Roberts spoke at the commencement ceremony of Cardigan Mountain School. As the 17th Chief Justice of the United States, appointed in 2005, he had also administered the presidential oath at inaugurations for Barack Obama, Donald Trump, and Joe Biden. A person like that might be expected to speak about order, honor, duty, and the future.
But he chose a sharper opening:
I am not going to wish you good luck.
I hope that, from time to time, you are treated unfairly, so that you come to understand the value of justice.
I hope you experience betrayal, because that is how you learn the importance of loyalty.
I hope you sometimes feel lonely, so that you do not take friendship for granted.
I hope you occasionally meet bad luck, so that you become conscious of chance in life, and understand that your success is not entirely deserved, and the failure of others is not entirely deserved either.
When you lose, I hope that every now and then your opponent gloats, so that you understand the value of sportsmanship.
I hope you are ignored, so that you learn the importance of listening to others.
I hope you have just enough pain to grow real empathy and compassion.
This is not a curse. It is a harder kind of blessing.
The sharpest part of Roberts’ speech is that he did not romanticize pain. He did not say hardship automatically makes people stronger. He did not pretend suffering is noble by itself. His point was colder and more useful: whether he wishes these things or not, they will happen. The question is not whether misfortune will arrive, but whether you can read the lesson inside it.
That is the center of the whole speech.
What this speech is really rejecting
Much motivational writing treats life like a clean reward system: work hard and you will succeed, be kind and you will be loved, be excellent and you will be seen, endure long enough and you will win.
Reality is not that tidy.
In reality, some people work hard and still lose. Some people are kind and still get betrayed. Some people are excellent and remain unseen for years. Some people get a seat at the table partly because of luck; others are pushed out by one bad turn of circumstance. If a person has an easy early life, it becomes tempting to confuse luck with virtue and other people’s hardship with personal failure.
That is the real value of Roberts’ anti-comfort message.
He is not praising suffering. He is dismantling a dangerous arrogance: the belief that everything you have is fully deserved, and everything others have lost is fully their fault.
Once that arrogance settles in, a person can no longer understand justice. Justice begins with admitting that people are shaped by circumstance, that luck can redirect a life, and that winners are not automatically superior while losers are not automatically inferior.
So, a person who has been treated unfairly has a chance to understand why rules matter.
A person who has been betrayed learns that promises are not decoration; they are scarce resources.
A person who has been lonely knows that friends are not background noise; they are part of how a person survives.
A person hit by bad luck loses some of the fantasy that everything came from the self alone.
A person who has lost and been humiliated understands that winning without crushing another person is a form of character.
A person who has been ignored knows that listening is not a polite gesture; it is a way of treating others as fully real.
A person who has truly hurt will be slower to tell someone else, “Just get over it.”
This is the meaning of hardship: it does not automatically make you better, but it gives you one chance to escape the prison of yourself.
Suffering is material; reflection is the forge
Of course, many people suffer and do not become kinder. They become harsher. People who have been hurt may turn around and hurt others. People who have been ignored may gain power and ignore others even more aggressively. Suffering has no moral value by itself. It is only raw material.
Whether that material becomes anything depends on reflection.
This is why Roberts’ speech feels more like education than ordinary encouragement. Ordinary encouragement places children inside an imaginary sterile greenhouse where storms never arrive. Real education helps them grow the inner structure needed to face storms when they do come.
Parents and teachers naturally want to protect the people they love. No one wants to watch a child be deceived, dismissed, humiliated, or casually knocked down by fate.
But life is not a red carpet that adults can clear in advance. You cannot delete the world’s complexity for another person. You cannot route them around every form of malice, chance, and failure. The most you can do is help them understand, when they fall, that falling is not the end of the world; when they are offended, that they do not have to become equally crude; and when they win, that they were once fragile too.
There is a Chinese saying: a sword is sharpened by grinding, and plum blossoms gain fragrance from bitter cold.
That line is often spoken too lightly, as if suffering alone guarantees flowering. A better reading is this: grinding only creates the possibility; it does not guarantee the result. Iron becomes a sword only if it is forged. A blossom gives fragrance only if there is life inside it.
Maturity is not success; it is not losing yourself
Having life go too smoothly when you are young is not always a blessing. If reality never pushes back, it is easy to mistake luck for ability, platform for talent, and other people’s support for one’s own greatness.
Late maturity is not merely success that arrives later. At a deeper level, it means this: after unfairness, a person can still pursue justice; after betrayal, still value loyalty; after loneliness, still treasure friendship; after bad luck, still remain humble; after pain, still stay sensitive to the pain of others.
That is harder than “success” itself.
Because success only proves that you reached a position. These qualities prove that you did not lose yourself on the way there.
Roberts’ anti-comfort wish is not really a wish for suffering. It is a framework for interpreting suffering:
-
When unfairness arrives, do not only learn hatred; learn why justice is worth protecting.
-
When betrayal arrives, do not only learn suspicion; learn why loyalty is worth cherishing.
-
When loneliness arrives, do not only close yourself off; learn why friendship is not guaranteed.
-
When failure arrives, do not only learn inferiority; learn to see luck and limitation.
-
When pain arrives, do not only learn endurance; learn to imagine the pain of others.
That is the real sign of maturity: not that you were never wounded, but that after being wounded, you did not turn the wound into an excuse to wound others.
A good blessing should not only wish you a smooth life.
A higher blessing is this: may you still extract justice, loyalty, humility, and empathy from the hardships that inevitably come.
The highest way to live is not to avoid every storm.
It is to come through the storm and still not become crude, cold, able only to win and unable to love.
Sources
- TIME transcript of Roberts’ 2017 Cardigan Mountain School commencement speech: I Wish You Bad Luck
- Supreme Court of the United States: John G. Roberts, Jr. biography